When you’re taking care of things around the house, it’s easy to wonder if one all-in-one tool could handle most of it. Multi-tools promise just that: a "multi-purpose tool" that sands, scrapes, cuts, and more. 

They’re a tempting option, especially if you’re short on storage space or just starting your power tool collection. At least, we know that's what drove us to buy! But how do these versatile tools stack up against full-size tools like jigsaws, grinders, sanders, and others made for one specific job? The short answer: it depends on what kind of work you’re doing at home.

Why a Multi-Tool Might Be All You Need

Multi-tools are made to be flexible for a variety of projects. Most come with multi-tool attachments for cutting, sanding, grinding, or scraping. Some plug in, others are battery-powered, and they’re small enough to stash in a drawer or tool box. 

Tools like the Dremel Multi-Max or another brand of oscillating multi-tool are especially popular with homeowners because they're the quickest option and can handle a variety of tasks.

Here’s when a multi-tool makes sense:

• You’re doing light work – Trimming wood, sanding furniture edges, removing grout
• You don’t have much storage – One small tool does the job of five
• You need something easy to carry – Good for quick fixes around the house
• You want flexibility – Swap out attachments to match the task

They’re also perfect for detail jobs. Need to cut out a piece of drywall without damaging the area around it? Or smooth a tight corner when refinishing a table? A multi-tool fits into tight spots where other tools can’t.

But they do have limits. Multi-tools aren’t made for speed or power.  Battery life on cordless tools can be limiting. They get the job done, but not as quickly or cleanly as a tool built for that task.

We Tested Husqvarna's Newest 15-in-1 Lawn and Landscape Tool

The new 330iK Combi Switch is certified compatible with attachments from the LK line, too.

Read More

When Individual Tools Work Better

If you’re doing a wide variety of home DIY projects more often—or working on something bigger than a weekend repair—individual tools can be a better investment. Many times they're easier to control, more powerful, and built for long-term use over extended periods.

Here’s how some of the most common individual tools stack up:

• Jigsaw – Great for cutting curves and a wide range of shapes in wood, plywood, or plastic
• Reciprocating saw – Good for heavy-duty tasks, like demo work, pruning, or rough cuts through wood and nails
• Angle grinder – Strong tool for cutting, grinding, or stripping metal and masonry
• Orbital sander or disc sander – Smooths large surfaces faster and more evenly
• Dremel – Technically a multi-tool, but mainly for detail work: carving, polishing, or tight sanding
• Swiss Army knife – Handy for everyday use, but not strong enough for real DIY tasks

These tools are usually more comfortable to hold and use, especially for longer projects. A full-size sander, for example, is easier on your hands and covers more surface area than a small multi-tool attachment.

If you’re updating a room, working on a deck, or fixing things regularly, full-size tools are worth it. You’ll work faster, and the results will look better.

Why Renting Tools Can Be Better Than Buying New

Tool rentals save money, reduce waste, and help the planet... especially tools for projects you only tackle once in a while.

Read More

Finding the Right Setup for Your Home

For most homeowners, it’s not about choosing one type of tool or the other—it’s about finding the right mix. A multi-tool is great for everyday fixes and light weekend jobs. Individual tools step in when you’re doing something bigger, like building, remodeling, or restoring.

Think about how you’ll use your tools:

• Do you take on home projects regularly? If so, invest in a few solid tools you’ll use again and again.
• Do you need something quick for small jobs? A multi-tool can stay charged and ready in a drawer.
• Do you care about the finish? A proper sander or jigsaw will leave cleaner results.
• Do you have space? If your tools live in a closet or hallway cabinet, a multi-tool keeps things simple.

Many homeowners start with a multi-tool, then add full-size tools over time as projects get bigger.

FAQ

Can a multi-tool really replace a jigsaw or sander?

Not fully. It can handle small cuts or quick sanding jobs, but it’s slower and doesn’t give the same clean finish. If you’re cutting a lot of wood or sanding large surfaces, the full-size version will save time and effort.

Is a Dremel Multi-Max enough for most home repairs?

It’s a helpful tool, especially for detail work, but it’s not built for heavy-duty repairs. Think of it as a great add-on, not a full replacement for tools like drills, saws, or sanders.