Homeowners choosing between electric and natural gas fireplaces tend to fixate on energy efficiency and, simply, which will work better for their space. There are many factors involved with any fireplace upgrade, and we're in the mindset that it's not an investment worth doing twice.
Efficiency considerations weigh heavily on factors like heat output, installation complexity, operating costs, and ambiance.
Electric fireplaces are energy efficient and are relatively easy to install and require less long-term maintenance. On the other hand, natural gas fireplaces boast high heat output and authentic flames but require professional installation and could have venting restrictions.
So the question of which is the best fireplace option really depends on individual priorities; do you value efficiency and convenience? You might lean towards an electric unit. If you want to prioritize heat output and ambiance, opt for natural gas.
How to Choose Between Gas and Electric
- Understand Heat Output. Assess the square footage of the space you want to heat. Gas fireplaces provide higher heat output; not only will they heat a room, they might be enough of a heating source for your whole home. They also cool more slowly putting off adequate heat even after they have been turned off. Electric fireplaces are best for heating individual rooms.
- Evaluate Energy Efficiency. If energy efficiency is a priority, electric fireplaces may be preferable, as they convert almost all energy into heat. They also use a cleaner source of energy if that is of importance.
- Installation costs and Requirements. Evaluate your willingness to deal with installation complexities. Gas fireplaces could require a propane tank or a gas line connection to be run, shut-off valves, carbon monoxide detectors, professional installation and fireplace vents. Electric fireplaces are generally easier to install, and depending on the model, may be as easy as plugging your model into a standard electric outlet.
- Ambiance Preferences. Consider whether the authentic experience of natural flame is crucial for you. Gas fireplaces often provide a more realistic flame ambiance. Although electric fireplaces can come with audio systems that provide the crackling sound effects of a traditional wood-burning fireplace.
- Venting Considerations. Assess your home's venting capabilities and restrictions. A direct vented gas fireplace will require a chimney and access to an exterior wall to draw in fresh air for combustion. Ventless gas fireplaces do not require a chimney for venting but some users are sensitive to the small amount of pollutants and moisture that can escape into the home. Electric fireplaces typically don't require venting and don't produce pollutants thus providing more flexibility in placement.
- Budget Constraints. Compare the upfront costs of both options, factoring in installation expenses. Electric fireplaces are often more budget-friendly in terms of installation.
- Maintenance and Long-Term Costs. Consider long-term maintenance and operational costs. Gas fireplaces could require a propane tank and monitoring a propane supply. Electric fireplaces usually require minimal maintenance like replacing a burnt-out bulb and tend to have lower operational costs based around the local cost of electricity.
- Placement Flexibility. Think about where you want the fireplace. Electric fireplaces can be better for zone heating and be placed virtually anywhere with an electrical outlet, while gas fireplaces tend to have more placement restrictions due to venting requirements.
- Practicality and Safety. Electric models are more like an electric heater and depend on a power source, so you can not rely on them during power outages. But gas units require regular maintenance tasks like chimney cleaning and gas line inspections to check for gas leaks.
- Personal Preferences. Ultimately, choose based on your personal preferences for heat source, ambiance, ease of installation, and the specific needs of your living space.
Do you need an electrician to install an electric fireplace insert?
Most electric fireplaces do not need professional help. Installation is simpler and cheaper than a gas insert.
- Many models plug into a standard wall outlet
- Setup often takes minutes
- No venting or gas lines
You might need an electrician (and permits!) if:
- The unit is hardwired
- It’s a large built-in model
- Your circuit needs an upgrade
Do electric fireplaces use a lot of electricity?
Electric fireplaces have about the energy use as a space heater.
- Around 1,500 watts on high heat
- Running daily can add $30–$50 per month, depending on rates
- Flame-only mode uses very little power. When off, it uses none.
Ways people keep costs lower:
- Use heat only when needed
- Run flame effects without heat
- Turn the unit fully off when not in use
How Do Ethanol Fireplaces Compare?
Ethanol fireplaces offer a unique alternative, distinct from electric and gas options. They burn bioethanol fuel which produces real flames without the need for venting or a chimney. They are a popular option for their simple installation and design flexibility, as they can be freestanding or wall-mounted, offering versatile placement.
While they provide ambiance, they typically offer less heat output compared to gas alternatives, making them more suitable for aesthetic enhancement rather than primary heating. They also emit moisture as a byproduct of the combustion process which though minimal, might be unwelcome in a small space or certain climates.
Ethanol fireplaces would be a great option for a secondary heat source. It appeals to those prioritizing design versatility, easy installation, and the absence of venting requirements, providing a contemporary and eco-friendly alternative in the realm of home heating solutions.
